Skip to main content
RtiTalk

[Special Feature] Philippines' Contradictory Stance Towards China Analyzed: Hawk-Dove Division, Long-Term Reliance on US Strategy Unchanged

RtiTalk 小編
RtiTalk 小編11d ago
The divergence in the Philippines' foreign affairs and security sectors regarding China has recently surfaced and drawn public attention. Analysts suggest that with the ASEAN Summit approaching on the 16th of this month in Manila, the Philippine authorities are engaging in dialogue with Beijing to avoid continued tensions in Philippine-China relations. However, their long-term stance towards China remains unchanged, and the United States will continue to maintain close cooperation with the Philippines on security and economic fronts. ASEAN Summit Approaching, Philippines Softens Stance Towards China Recently, the Philippine government has shown conflicting attitudes towards China. Since the end of last year (2025), security officials and the Chinese Embassy in the Philippines have been exchanging sharp words over sovereignty disputes in the South China Sea. On the other hand, Foreign Minister Ma. Theresa Lazaro, in a call with Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi earlier this month, expressed a desire to "maintain stable bilateral relations" with China through dialogue. A few days later, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs issued a rare statement criticizing some officials for making remarks on China and South China Sea issues that undermine the government's foreign policy, potentially damaging the Philippines' international credibility. Although the Philippine Ministry of Foreign Affairs did not publicly name the targets of its criticism, it clearly pointed fingers at Defense Minister Gilberto Teodoro Jr. and Coast Guard spokesperson Jay Tarriela. Both have repeatedly condemned China's expansionist actions in the South China Sea. In September of this year, Teodoro received a note from a Chinese representative during the Seoul Defense Dialogue questioning the legitimacy of the Philippines' South China Sea claims, to which he publicly responded by asking the representative to "have some shame." With the same government exhibiting two starkly different attitudes, one can't help but wonder if Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr.'s strategy towards China has shifted. Wang Wen-yueh, an associate professor at the Graduate Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, National Chi Nan University, points out that the Philippine government's current softening of its stance towards China and emphasis on dialogue is primarily for "crisis management" before the ASEAN Summit, aiming to de-escalate bilateral tensions. Wang Wen-yueh said: "(Original sound) The main purpose of this dialogue is not to completely change past positions. The primary reason is that the Philippine Ministry of Foreign Affairs' role is to act as a stable channel. Meanwhile, the Philippine Coast Guard and its Ministry of Defense will continue to demand transparency and exert external pressure. These two directions are essentially a deliberate division of labor, not a contradiction in policy." China's Hybrid Threats Intensify, Philippines Strengthens Cooperation with US and Japan Lee Chun-yi, an associate research fellow at the National Security Institute, Defense Research Institute, who studies non-traditional security theory and hybrid threats, notes that China has increasingly expanded its "gray zone" activities against the Philippines in recent years, utilizing local Chinese communities for infiltration and united front work. For example, former Chinese-Filipino mayor Guo Huaping was elected under a false identity and accused of being a CCP spy. Additionally, several Chinese nationals have been arrested on suspicion of collecting military intelligence within the Philippines. These recurring incidents have led the Marcos Jr. administration to maintain a higher level of caution towards cooperation with China, with diplomatic dialogue before the ASEAN Summit being merely a temporary measure. Lee Chun-yi believes that compared to China, the Marcos Jr. administration prioritizes developing cooperative relationships with like-minded countries such as the United States and Japan. The US and the Philippines signed a Mutual Defense Treaty as early as 1951. After Marcos Jr. took office in 2022, he further opened several military bases in the country for US use, clearly signaling a US-centric security policy. In terms of economic development, Marcos Jr. has also shown a more proactive attitude towards the United States and its allies. In 2024, the Philippine government invited the US and Japan to jointly launch the "Luzon Economic Corridor" initiative, aiming to boost economic growth in the Philippines through strengthened investments in infrastructure and supply chains on Luzon Island. In April of this year, the Philippines also joined the US-promoted "Pax Silica" initiative, which aims to establish an AI and advanced manufacturing hub in Tarlac province. Lee Chun-yi said: "(Original sound) Within the broader context of US-China competition, by leveraging the Philippines' own conditions, whether land, environment, or human resources, it attracts the US and its allies to build what we call a 'non-red supply chain' in the First Island Chain, allowing the Philippines to better integrate into the supply chains of the US, Japan, and other democratic countries. I believe this is the strategic direction of the Marcos Jr. administration." Philippines Choosing Sides Amidst US-China Competition? Scholars: South China Sea is Key However, scholars remind us that people often assume the Philippines' stance towards the US and China is a result of choosing between two major powers, overlooking the fact that China's continuous expansion of hegemony in the South China Sea is the primary reason forcing Southeast Asian countries like the Philippines, Vietnam, and Indonesia to turn towards the United States. Lee Chun-yi points out that during the early period of former President Rodrigo Duterte's administration, he deliberately emphasized economic relations with China and declared an end to security cooperation with the US. Later, he realized that Beijing not only failed to effectively implement bilateral economic and trade agreements but also continuously asserted its sovereignty claims in the South China Sea. This led him to change his attitude and adopt a tougher stance against China. The entire process illustrates how China's assertive actions in the South China Sea have negatively impacted Philippine-China relations. With the ASEAN Summit and the APEC Leaders Meeting in Shenzhen approaching, will this create an opportunity for Marcos Jr. to improve Philippine-China relations? Wang Wen-yueh states that since Marcos Jr.'s presidential term has less than half remaining, the Philippine government has no strong motivation at this time to change its consistent stance of strengthening security cooperation with Japan, the US, and Australia, and counterbalancing China. However, observations on whether Philippine-China relations improve can be made based on indicators such as Marcos Jr.'s interactions with Chinese leadership at the ASEAN and APEC meetings, whether Philippine security officials continue to criticize China, and whether resupply missions to the Second Thomas Shoal can proceed as usual. Source Link: https://www.rti.org.tw/news?uid=3&pid=1050799

How does this article make you feel?

0 people reacted

Comments (0)

No comments yet